How to read these figures
Each figure is the share of businesses in the sample, with its 95% margin of error. Where fewer than five businesses fall on either side of a figure, no margin is given, and the figure reads “too few to give a margin”. A figure based on fewer than 50 businesses is not published. A series whose input is not yet available is marked withheld, never shown as zero. Each chart carries its label: register-backed figures rest on a provision of the law the site was graded under; observations are what our browser saw, reported without a legal grade. The Index describes what public websites showed on the day of the scan. It is a diagnostic indicator, not a legal opinion, and it does not state that any business complies, or fails to comply, with any law.
The overall band
The band each business's website was shown, under the law its scan was graded against. Four categories: Low, Medium, High, and No overall band, which is never folded into Low.
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
Overall band, by the law the site was scored under
All sites
Low 24.3%Medium 40.4%High 5.0%No overall band 30.3%
n = 1,957 · margins up to ±2.2 pts
Singapore
Low 24.6%Medium 36.0%High 4.6%No overall band 34.8%
n = 977 · margins up to ±3.0 pts
Malaysia
Low 24.1%Medium 44.8%High 5.3%No overall band 25.8%
n = 980 · margins up to ±3.1 pts
Low, Medium and High count the findings Dxtra could link to a provision of the law it graded the website against, each provision once. No overall band means none could be linked; it is not a Low result.
- Low
- At least one finding linked to the law, with no high-severity finding and no more than two medium ones.
- Medium
- One high-severity finding, or three or more medium ones.
- High
- Two or more high-severity findings.
- No overall band
- No finding linked to a provision of the law. It is not a Low result, and it does not mean the website has no issues.
Websites that handle sensitive data, such as health or financial data, are held to stricter thresholds. The band describes the website's public pages on the day of the scan, under Methodology v1.19. It is not a legal opinion.
Differences between the two countries partly reflect how many provisions of each country's law Dxtra's register grades, not only what the websites show. The figures should not be read as a ranking of the two countries.
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
Number of grounded provisions per site
All sites
0 30.3%1 63.3%2 6.4%3 0.1%4 or more 0.0%
n = 1,957 · margins up to ±2.1 pts
Singapore
0 34.8%1 59.9%2 5.3%3 0.0%4 or more 0.0%
n = 977 · margins up to ±3.1 pts
Malaysia
0 25.8%1 66.6%2 7.4%3 0.1%4 or more 0.0%
n = 980 · margins up to ±3.0 pts
Privacy-officer contact
Whether the website publishes a way to reach someone about personal data. Read from public pages by a reading agent; a person then checked a sample of the sites.
Consent banners
What happened when a cookie banner was present, and when our browser chose Reject All.
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Consent banner shown
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Consent banner shown, tracker requests fired before consent
Malaysia
Not published: fewer than 50 businesses (n = 30)
Who receives the data
The third-party vendors a website contacted before consent, named by the tracker catalog, and the categories they fall in.
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Third-party tracker vendors contacted before consent, per site
All sites
None 28.2%1 to 2 22.5%3 to 5 40.3%6 to 10 8.8%More than 10 0.2%
n = 1,811 · margins up to ±2.3 pts
Singapore
None 26.3%1 to 2 21.7%3 to 5 40.8%6 to 10 10.9%More than 10 0.3%
n = 905 · margins up to ±3.2 pts
Malaysia
None 30.0%1 to 2 23.4%3 to 5 39.8%6 to 10 6.7%More than 10 0.0%
n = 906 · margins up to ±3.2 pts
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Share of sites contacting at least one vendor in each tracker category before consent
- 1Unclassified86.6%
- 2Advertising54.4%
- 3Analytics46.8%
- 4Email/marketing1.2%
- 5Customer interaction0.1%
- 6Social0.0%
- 7Telemetry0.0%
- Share of businesses where each appears · n = 1,811
86.6% of the websites contacted at least one tracker not yet assigned a category, so each category's share is a lower bound.
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Most common third-party vendors contacted before consent
- 1Google Marketing46.6%
- 2Google37.2%
- 3Google Analytics36.1%
- 4Facebook27.3%
- 5Microsoft Clarity7.5%
- 6Google AdServices7.3%
- 7Google Merchant Center6.0%
- 8TikTok Analytics2.8%
- 9Hotjar2.7%
- 10Klaviyo2.0%
- 11LinkedIn Analytics2.0%
- 12HubSpot1.8%
- 13LinkedIn Ads1.7%
- 14Google Syndication1.2%
- 15Bing Ads0.8%
- Share of businesses where each appears · n = 1,811
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Vendors contacted before consent: the vendor's stated home country
| Vendor | Websites with a request to it before consent | Company named in the vendor's own privacy notice or terms | The vendor's stated home country |
|---|
| Google Marketing | 46.6% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| Google | 37.2% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| Google Analytics | 36.1% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| Facebook | 27.3% | Meta Platforms, Inc. | United States |
|---|
| Microsoft Clarity | 7.5% | Microsoft Corporation (or one of its affiliates) | United States |
|---|
| Google AdServices | 7.3% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| Google Merchant Center | 6.0% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| TikTok Analytics | 2.8% | TikTok Pte. Ltd. | Singapore |
|---|
| Hotjar | 2.7% | Withheld: the notice names a group of companies, not one company. |
|---|
| Klaviyo | 2.0% | Klaviyo, Inc. | United States |
|---|
| LinkedIn Analytics | 2.0% | LinkedIn Corporation | United States |
|---|
| HubSpot | 1.8% | HubSpot, Inc. | United States |
|---|
| LinkedIn Ads | 1.7% | LinkedIn Corporation | United States |
|---|
| Google Syndication | 1.2% | Google LLC | United States |
|---|
| Bing Ads | 0.8% | Microsoft Corporation | United States |
|---|
Share of businesses where each vendor appears · n = 1,811
This is where each vendor says it is based, in its own published privacy notice or terms, read between October 11 and 18, 2026. It is not where any website's data goes or is stored, and it is not a finding against any website. Each row was checked against the vendor's own notice or terms; no regulator has reviewed this table. For Google, the company Google's Terms of Service name for users of its services (country version: Malaysia, read October 18, 2026). For Google Merchant Center, the company Merchant Center's own Terms of Service name (Malaysia and Singapore versions of June 1, 2026, read October 27, 2026), and its country as Google's Terms of Service state it (read October 18, 2026). For Microsoft Clarity, the company in the words of Clarity's own Terms of Use, and its country as Clarity's documentation states it (both read October 27, 2026).
The privacy notice
Whether a privacy notice was found, whether it is dated, and what it says about processors and transfers.
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
No privacy notice found on the site
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Privacy notice link present but the notice did not load
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
No date found on the privacy notice
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Privacy notice does not name the third-party services seen receiving requests
This series does not count services from large platforms such as Google, Meta, Microsoft and Amazon, or consent tools, so it shows fewer websites than a full comparison would.
Read by our scan; a person checked a random sample of 20Read by the scan, checked by a person on a sample
Privacy notice does not name an analytics, advertising, or similar service that loaded before any cookie choice
Base: 690 websites whose privacy notice the scan read, whose browser check ran from a local address, and where at least one analytics, advertising, or similar service loaded before any cookie choice. A person at Dxtra checked a random sample of 20 of the websites counted here, about two weeks after the scans, against the privacy notice and any cookie policy or vendor list it links to. The person agreed with the scan on all 19 that could still be checked; one notice could no longer be opened. The checker is Dxtra's founder, not an independent reviewer, and could see the scan's result while checking. The check covered only websites the scan counted here, not those it read as naming every service. A sample of 20 can show the scan is usually right on this question, not that it is never wrong. The scan looks for each service's company or brand name in the text of the privacy notice it read; unlike the person, it does not open a cookie policy or vendor list the notice links to. The scan compares only services it recognizes, so it may miss some that a notice does not name.
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
No cross-border transfer disclosure
In Malaysia, under the Personal Data Protection Commissioner's guideline on cross-border transfers, a business that transfers personal data overseas may tell people about it in its privacy notice or in another written notice. This figure reads only the business's website, so it cannot see a notice given another way.
Dxtra's view of good practice, not graded as a legal dutyDxtra benchmark priority
Age of the privacy notice
All sites
Undated 64.5%Under 6 months 12.2%6 to 12 months 3.3%12 to 24 months 3.7%Over 24 months 16.3%
n = 938 · margins up to ±3.1 pts
Singapore
Undated 61.6%Under 6 months 11.5%6 to 12 months 3.5%12 to 24 months 4.0%Over 24 months 19.4%
n = 521 · margins up to ±4.2 pts
Malaysia
Undated 68.1%Under 6 months 12.9%6 to 12 months 3.1%12 to 24 months 3.4%Over 24 months 12.5%
n = 417 · margins up to ±4.5 pts
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Privacy notice text identical to another site's notice
All sites
too few to give a margin · n = 955
Singapore
too few to give a margin · n = 528
Malaysia
too few to give a margin · n = 427
Rights and collection
Routes for access and correction requests, and forms that collect personal data.
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
No visible access or correction route (Singapore)
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
No visible access or correction route (Malaysia)
AI
What privacy notices say about AI, and the chat widgets websites run.
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Privacy notice mentions artificial intelligence or automated decision-making
Seen by our scan, not graded against the lawObservation
Notice describes significant automated decision-making
All sites
too few to give a margin · n = 955
Singapore
too few to give a margin · n = 528
Malaysia
too few to give a margin · n = 427
What the law expects
The provisions of Singapore and Malaysian law that the scans engaged, in the words of the register.
Linked by Dxtra to a provision of privacy lawRegister-backed
Websites with at least one finding linked to a provision of the law they were graded against
This is the other side of No overall band: on the same 1,957 websites, 69.7% had at least one finding Dxtra's register links to a provision of the law, and 30.3% had none.
What is working
Practices that go beyond the minimum.
What is working
Privacy notice updated within six months
What is working
Transparency hub or center published
All sites
too few to give a margin · n = 2,000
Singapore
too few to give a margin · n = 1,000
Malaysia
too few to give a margin · n = 1,000
Observed privacy practices
A secondary 0 to 100 figure for the privacy practices seen on a website's public pages. Never the headline.
Secondary indicator
Observed privacy practices (0 to 100), mean
All sites
18.9 of 100 · mean · n = 976
Singapore
18.8 of 100 · mean · n = 542
Malaysia
19.0 of 100 · mean · n = 434
A website scan can show at most 71 on this scale; the rest covers practices that cannot be seen from public pages.
Series not published in this edition, and why.
| Tracker requests persist after Reject All | Not published: fewer than 50 businesses (n = 38) |
| Privacy notice does not mention third parties or service providers at all, on sites where third-party requests were seen | Not published: the measured accuracy of this finding has not yet reached the publication gate |
| Live-chat widget with no notice | Not published: the measured accuracy of this finding has not yet reached the publication gate |
| Provisions most often engaged, by law | Not measured |
Where these numbers come from
Published October 16, 2026. Websites were scanned between October 12 and October 14, 2026; 85 of them were measured in a second pass on October 14, 2026. Revision 1.1.2.
Made by the Dxtra Privacy Scanner at build 562c60d under Methodology v1.19 (snapshot SHA-256 8bc9466aa038…) — the methodology as it stood. Dxtra Regulator Reference v2.0 (Dxtra's own reference, not issued or reviewed by any regulator). Runs idx-2026q4-fill-v11, idx-2026q4-full-v119, idx-2026q4-stability-v119, idx-2026q4-topup-589. Data pack SHA-256 9a3ee4eaa486….
- 2026-10-14: final pack from run(s) idx-2026q4-full-v119, idx-2026q4-topup-589
- 2026-10-18: Revision 1.0.1: every share and margin is now kept exact and rounded once, half-up, from its count, so some figures move by 0.1 point (none of the headline figures); series labels as agreed (No privacy notice found on the site; No privacy-officer contact on the website; No date found on the privacy notice, now an observation). The counts, sample and method do not change.
- 2026-10-19: Revision 1.0.2: the vendors' stated home countries are published, from a table checked by Dxtra against each vendor's own privacy notice or terms (14 of the 15 vendors named; Hotjar withheld). "No date found on the privacy notice" now uses the same reading as the age chart: a notice counts as undated where no date was read from it, by the scan or from its text, whatever its language. The counts of every other series do not change.
- 2026-10-19: Display corrections; no count changes. No margin is given where fewer than five businesses fall on either side of a figure. The series on services not named in the privacy notice is labeled "Privacy notice does not name the third-party services seen receiving requests", with a note that it does not count large platforms or consent tools. Capability maturity is described as the privacy practices seen on a website's public pages, with its 71-point ceiling for a website scan and its base of websites where a privacy notice was read. The live-chat series' base is all businesses in the sample. The remainder of the vendor league is labeled "Other vendors (combined)" and is not ranked. A line under the age chart explains why it counts more notices as undated than "No date found on the privacy notice".
- 2026-10-26: Revision 1.1: every place in the draw has one measured website, 1,000 in each country. Twelve places, two in Singapore and ten in Malaysia, were filled on October 22, 2026 from the reserve in rank order, and three places that had been measured twice now keep only the website they measured first; this moves each figure outside the tracker series by 0.4 points or less. The tracker series are read through the tracker catalogue as of October 19, 2026, with Dxtra's own additions as of October 21, 2026; this moves the tracker series only, by up to 7.1 points, and brings Microsoft Clarity and Google Merchant Center into the vendor league, where their stated home country is withheld until their own notice or terms are checked. Observed privacy practices (formerly the capability maturity indicator) is now rounded once, as the scanner rounds it, so some websites' figures are one point lower. In two Singapore places, a reserve website was taken out of rank order; both are kept as measured.
- 2026-10-27: Revision 1.1.1: the vendor table prints the company and stated home country for Microsoft Clarity and Google Merchant Center, read from each one's own documents; the counts do not change.
- 2026-11-02: Revision 1.1.2: a new series, "Privacy notice does not name an analytics, advertising, or similar service that loaded before any cookie choice", is read from the same records and the same archived privacy notices, and becomes a key finding after a person's check of a random sample of 20 of the websites it counts; the first key finding, and its homepage card, now read "had no privacy-officer contact on the website", matching its chart. No other figure changes.